Skip to content
Menu
AN AN

Automotive News

  • Automotive News
  • Used Cars
  • Automotive Deals
  • Automotive repair
  • Automotive Accessories
AN AN

Automotive News

A fraud tale: Misdirection of parts

By on June 13, 2023

Image credit: Depositphotos. com

One type of fraud a shop can fall victim to is a misdirection of sales part. A red flag for any shop would be a discrepancy between what the shop thinks it’s making on parts and what is actually being realized.

Hunt Demarest, a senior accountant who specializes in working with automotive repair shops with Paar, Melis & Associates, had a client suffer through this kind of scheme.

The client’s books were a mess. In the process of cleaning it up, parts margin data was compared to the shop management software. In Demarest’s eyes, so long as the numbers ended up in the same ballpark, he’d be fine with what he found.

There was indeed a gap. But the difference was more of a gulf. The SMS showed a parts margin of about 50 per cent; the accounting software came in at -15 per cent.

“You think that you’re selling parts for twice what you pay for them. In actuality, you’re buying more parts and you’re selling,” Demarest said during the session, protecting Your Company, at this year’s Midwest Auto Care Alliance Vision Hi-Tech Training and Expo.

Of course, the shop owner’s initial reaction was that the accountant was wrong. A natural reaction, Demarest said, because it’s something the shop owner didn’t want to see — so there must be some kind of mistake on the accountant’s end.

“This is pretty cut and dry. Numbers do not lie. Look at this. Look at your parts cost of goods sold. Look at all the transactions,” Demarest said.

So they did some digging. They found credit card statements saying they had paid thousands of dollars recently to their jobber. But the SMS showed nothing bought from them in months.

But when Demarest mentioned the jobber’s name to the shop owner, he was able to put it together. The owner of the store was friends with a technician, the shop owner fired a few months before. The ex-tech opened his own shop, bought the parts from the jobber and charged it to his previous employer. He was able to do this because he knew how to exploit the system since the shop’s book was not kept up to date.

And that’s something that can easily happen in any shop. Thinking about it, Demarest said: A tech leaves and starts his own shop. He knows the parts guys well but doesn’t tell them he’s left. He orders parts from the store and tells the counterperson to put them on his old shop’s tab.

Of course, there would be clues, such as the tech driving the jobber to pick up the parts. But the guy at the counter isn’t paid enough to really look into those questions. So the scheme lives on.

Demarest gave a few tips to pass on to jobbers, such as any orders from an unrecognized number should be ignored; certain people can only place orders; and no walk-in orders.

And, he pointed out, the shop owner wasn’t looking at his financial statements. The tech probably knew this and exploited that to his advantage.

“This has been going on for God knows how long and the only reason that was caught is because they actually started looking at the financial statements in the correct format,” Demarest said.

Category: Automotive repair
Tags: bar california, bureau automotive repair consumer assistance program

Post navigation

Millions Of Kia Cars Could Have Dangerous Airbags
Toyota future EV plans include batteries with 900-mile range

Related Posts

Aviva Canada launches auto repair centers

June 17, 2023
Read More

What To Consider Before Buying Tires for Your Subaru

May 28, 2023
Read More

Stolen auto repair tools in Caledon leads to charge for North York man

July 7, 2023
Read More

Recent Posts

  • Travel + Leisure Archives
  • Online Costume Buying In Sri Lanka
  • Ecotour Car Accessories are on sale at Amazon
  • SPOTLIGHT: 15 questions with Corey Smith
  • Crisis Recovery – How Automotive Suppliers Can Get Back On The Road To Success

Tags

automotive automotive news canada automotive news china automotive news data center automotive news europe automotive news ford automotive news jobs automotive news logo automotive news magazine automotive news subscription automotive news subscription discount automotive news uk auto news now best new car incentives breaking auto news business buying car industry news car news websites china automotive news current automotive news education estate fashion headlines health house information jewellery jewelry latest latest automotive news latest news on automobile industry latest news on automotive industry newest news in the automotive industry online pictures south gate used car dealers sport technology top automotive news travel updates us automotive industry news

About Us

  • Contact Us
  • Disclosure Policy
  • Sitemap
Seedbacklink

Patner links

©2025 AN | WordPress Theme by Superb WordPress Themes

WhatsApp us